Blog

The first question I got: isn't that already on YouTube

On November 10, I posted an introduction to Plainfeed in an online community. A few comments came in, and the first one asked how it was different from YouTube's subscriptions tab. "Isn't that a built-in feature?" came up twice.

It was a fair question

Honestly, it's not wrong. YouTube has a subscriptions tab, and it lists videos from the channels you follow, newest first. I'd been using it long before I built Plainfeed.

So my first thought reading those comments was: of everything that's already built in, what do we actually do differently? Show that first. Instead of listing features, I thought back to where the subscriptions tab had actually tripped me up.

Three places the subscriptions tab lost me

In short: picking videos was fine in the subscriptions tab. The trouble was while watching, and after.

First, Shorts were mixed in. Scrolling down through new videos from channels I follow, I'd keep hitting a shelf of Shorts in between.

Second, it didn't end. I'd watch everything new from my subscriptions, top to bottom, and when the last video finished, autoplay would start something YouTube's recommendation algorithm picked. And I'd end up watching it without meaning to. The moment I thought I was done was the moment it started again.

Third, the dates blurred. The tab shows times like "3 hours ago," but after a day everything becomes "1 day ago," "2 days ago." On the morning of November 12, I counted 15 videos labeled "1 day ago" in my desktop subscriptions tab. Once a day passed, it was hard to tell when anything had actually gone up.

The subscriptions tab and a timeline by day, side by side. On the left, the subscriptions tab shows rough times like "12 hours ago" and "1 day ago," a Shorts shelf sits in the middle, and after the last video, algorithmic recommendations keep playing. On the right, the timeline is split into Today and Yesterday with upload times, and it stops once the unwatched videos are done.
The same subscription videos look different in three ways: Shorts, dates, and what happens at the end (simplified drawing).

What about turning off watch history

The comments had another suggestion. If you turn off YouTube watch history, you can see mostly videos from your subscriptions instead of what the recommendation algorithm picks. YouTube Help says that with watch history off and little recent history, homepage recommendations are removed.

I don't know this approach well yet. I haven't tried it, so I can't say what goes away or what gets inconvenient when watch history is off. I don't know whether subscriptions fill that space, either. I plan to follow the settings myself and write it up in the next guide.

That said, the three places I got stuck were the subscriptions tab and what happens after a video ends, not the home page. I'll check how turning off watch history affects those, and write down what I find.

How I answered

In short: the same subscription videos, without anything mixed in, with an end, and with clear dates.

Replying to those comments, I summed up how Plainfeed differs from the subscriptions tab:

Looking back, those four lined up exactly with what I set out to build. If anything, the question helped me find the words to explain it.

Now

Using it myself, I can reliably watch just the videos from the channels I meant to watch, and then leave.

It's not a big change, but it feels like a digital detox to me. I didn't quit YouTube. I just watch what I came for and get out.

Wrapping up

"Isn't that a built-in feature?" is now how I open my introductions. Saying how it differs from the subscriptions tab gets the point across much faster than describing what it does.

In the next post, I'll try the other approach from the comments myself: how to keep videos picked by YouTube's recommendation algorithm off your home page.

Keep reading

All posts